Social IssuesHard DifficultyIn the news, Sept 2026

Is reservation policy still relevant in modern India?

Facts checked 29 September 2026 for the CAT 2026 cycle

Quick Answer

WAT Topic: "Is reservation policy still relevant in modern India?" - social category, hard difficulty. Consider 2 perspectives for a balanced essay.

Both Perspectives

Still Relevant

  • 1Caste discrimination persists in hiring, housing, marriages
  • 2SC/ST representation in corporate boardrooms still minimal
  • 3Social mobility data shows continued inequality
  • 4Reservation is compensatory, not charity

Needs Reform

  • 1Creamy layer should be extended to all categories
  • 2Economic criteria should supplement caste criteria
  • 3Sunset clauses to review periodically
  • 4Focus on quality education access instead

Sample Essay Structure

Introduction

Reference Census 2027, which will record caste for every resident during its February 2027 population enumeration, and the pending demand for a creamy layer among SC and ST candidates. State: still needed, but needs reform.

Body Paragraphs

1

Para 1: Evidence that discrimination persists

2

Para 2: Valid critiques of current implementation

3

Para 3: Proposed reforms (economic criteria, creamy layer, better data)

Conclusion

Don't abolish, but evolve the policy with better data and clear review points.

Key Statistics to Use

📊

Until the 2011 Census only Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes were counted by caste; the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs decided on 30 April 2025 to include caste enumeration in Census 2027 (PIB)

📊

Census 2027 population enumeration, which will record caste, is scheduled for February 2027 (PIB)

📊

In August 2026 the Centre told the Supreme Court that the creamy layer concept does not apply to SCs and STs (The Hindu, 6 August 2026)

Common Mistakes

Taking an extreme anti-reservation stance

Not knowing the constitutional basis (Articles 15, 16)

Ignoring data on continued discrimination

Pro Tip

This is a sensitive topic. Lead with empathy and data, not ideology. Know the 50% cap from the Indra Sawhney case and the Census 2027 caste enumeration.

Writing Framework (Applies to All WAT)

Aristotle

Rhetoric (4th Century BC)

Insight: Persuasion requires ethos (credibility), pathos (emotion), and logos (logic) working together.

How to apply: Structure your WAT with logical arguments (logos), establish credibility through data/examples (ethos), and connect to human impact (pathos). IIM evaluators look for all three.

Chip & Dan Heath

Made to Stick (2007)

Insight: Ideas that stick are Simple, Unexpected, Concrete, Credible, Emotional, and tell Stories (SUCCESs).

How to apply: Open with an unexpected fact or angle. Use concrete examples, not abstractions. Ground arguments in credible data. Make it memorable.

Steven Pinker

The Sense of Style (2014)

Insight: Good writing is about showing the reader something in the world, not performing your knowledge.

How to apply: Don't write to impress—write to illuminate. Avoid jargon and pompous language. Show you understand the issue, don't just list points.

George Orwell

Politics and the English Language (1946)

Insight: Clear thinking leads to clear writing. Never use a long word where a short one will do.

How to apply: Prefer active voice. Cut unnecessary words. If you can cut a word, cut it. Clarity beats complexity in 200-word essays.

School-Specific WAT Styles

IIM Ahmedabad

Values original thinking and nuanced positions over conventional wisdom.

Tip: IIMA loves contrarian but well-reasoned takes. Don't be afraid to challenge the premise of the topic itself.

IIM Bangalore

Practical, business-oriented evaluation. Values structured thinking.

Tip: IIMB appreciates when you connect topics to business/management implications. Always include "so what" for managers.

IIM Calcutta

Rigorous analytical approach. Values data and economic reasoning.

Tip: IIMC loves numbers. Include at least one relevant statistic. Show you understand economic trade-offs.

IIM Lucknow

Balanced evaluation of content and expression.

Tip: IIML values clear structure. Use explicit transitions and signposting.

XLRI Jamshedpur

Ethics-focused, values human-centric perspectives.

Tip: XLRI's Jesuit heritage means they value ethical dimensions. Always consider the human/social impact angle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What stance should I take on "Is reservation policy still relevant in modern India?"?

There's no "right" stance. What matters is taking a clear position and defending it well. This is a sensitive topic. Lead with empathy and data, not ideology. Know the 50% cap from the Indra Sawhney case and the Census 2027 caste enumeration.

Will "Is reservation policy still relevant in modern India?" come in the WAT?

Nobody outside the institute can say. IIMs set the essay topic on the day. This topic is tied to an issue that was current in September 2026, and the statistics on this page carry their source and date, so use it for practice.

How do I structure my WAT on this topic?

Reference Census 2027, which will record caste for every resident during its February 2027 population enumeration, and the pending demand for a creamy layer among SC and ST candidates. State: still needed, but needs reform. Your body should cover: Para 1: Evidence that discrimination persists; Para 2: Valid critiques of current implementation; Para 3: Proposed reforms (economic criteria, creamy layer, better data).

Related WAT Topics

Key Takeaways

  • 1Introduction: Reference Census 2027, which will record caste for every resident during its February 2027 population enumeration, and the pending demand for a creamy layer among SC and ST candidates. State: still needed, but needs reform.
  • 2Key argument: Para 1: Evidence that discrimination persists
  • 3Until the 2011 Census only Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes were counted by caste; the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs decided on 30 April 2025 to include caste enumeration in Census 2027 (PIB)
  • 4Census 2027 population enumeration, which will record caste, is scheduled for February 2027 (PIB)
  • 5Pro tip: This is a sensitive topic. Lead with empathy and data, not ideology. Know the 50% cap from the Indra Sawhney case and the Census 2027 caste enumeration.

You've studied the topic. Ready to defend it under pressure?

Our AI simulates the follow-up questions panels ask after reading your essay — testing if you truly understand what you wrote.

Experience a Mock Interview